Written methods

Column subtraction with exchanging, explained

Column subtraction with exchanging is what you do when, in one column, the top digit is smaller than the bottom digit: 2 − 7, for example. You exchange one ten from the next column for ten ones, so there are enough to subtract. You may also hear it called borrowing or regrouping: it's the same idea.

Ages 7–105 min read
In shortIf the top digit is too small, take one ten from the column on the left (it goes down by 1) and add ten to your column. Then subtract as normal.

Why do we need to exchange?

Take 52 − 27. We always start with the ones: 2 − 7… you can't take 7 away from 2. You need more ones, so you get them from the tens.

Before anything else, your child needs to be comfortable with one idea: 52 is 5 tens and 2 ones, but it's also 4 tens and 12 ones. If that isn't clear yet, go back to place value (tens and ones) with objects.

The method, step by step

  1. Ones: 2 − 7, not possible. Exchange one ten: the 5 tens become 4, and the 2 ones become 12.
  2. 12 − 7 = 5. Write 5 in the ones column.
  3. Tens: 4 − 2 = 2. Write 2 in the tens column.
41
52
−27
25
Exchanging: one ten moves into the ones. The 5 becomes 4 (small digit above), and the 2 becomes 12.

Answer: 52 − 27 = 25. In school books, you'll usually see the 5 crossed out with a small 4 above it, and a small 1 written next to the 2.

Why it works: show it with base ten

Exchanging is much easier to understand with base ten equipment (or coins):

The written method is just a record of this swap.

The tricky case: zeros (403 − 157)

Ones: 3 − 7 isn't possible, but you can't exchange from the tens: there are none! So go to the hundreds:

  1. Exchange one hundred: the 4 becomes 3, and the tens become 10.
  2. Now exchange one ten: the tens become 9, and the ones become 13.
  3. 13 − 7 = 6, 9 − 5 = 4, 3 − 1 = 2.

Answer: 403 − 157 = 246.

TipTo check a subtraction, use addition: answer + bottom number = top number. Here, 246 + 157 = 403. ✔

A note for parents: "it's not how I learned it!"

Some parents learned a different method, sometimes called equal addition or "pay back": instead of taking one ten from the top, you add ten to the top digit and one ten to the bottom number. It gives the same answer, but schools in England teach exchanging, because it can be shown with base ten equipment. To avoid confusion, use the method your child's school uses: have a look in their exercise book.

How to explain it to your child

The most common mistakes

  1. Taking the smaller digit from the bigger one in each column: for 52 − 27, working out 7 − 2 = 5 in the ones and 5 − 2 = 3 in the tens, giving 35. This is the most common mistake of all!
  2. Forgetting to reduce the tens after exchanging.
  3. Getting stuck on zeros (403 − 157).
  4. Lining the numbers up badly: ones must be under ones.
In EasyMaths, your child fills in the column subtraction digit by digit, with instant feedback.
In EasyMaths, your child fills in the column subtraction digit by digit, with instant feedback.EasyMaths exercise

Worked examples

63 − 28
3 − 8 isn't possible: exchange a ten, 13 − 8 = 5. Tens: 5 − 2 = 3. 63 − 28 = 35. Check: 35 + 28 = 63 ✔
81 − 47
11 − 7 = 4. Tens: 7 − 4 = 3. 81 − 47 = 34.
524 − 168
4 − 8: exchange, 14 − 8 = 6 (tens go from 2 to 1). 1 − 6: exchange, 11 − 6 = 5 (hundreds go from 5 to 4). 4 − 1 = 3. 524 − 168 = 356. Check: 356 + 168 = 524 ✔
700 − 254
Exchange across the zeros: 7 → 6, tens become 9, ones become 10. 10 − 4 = 6; 9 − 5 = 4; 6 − 2 = 4. 700 − 254 = 446.

Frequently asked questions

Is exchanging the same as borrowing?

Yes. Exchanging, borrowing and regrouping all describe the same step: swapping one ten for ten ones (or one hundred for ten tens) so you have enough to subtract. Schools in England usually say "exchanging".

When do children learn column subtraction with exchanging?

In England, column subtraction is introduced in Year 3, with exchanging, and extended to four-digit numbers in Year 4.

How do you check a subtraction?

With addition: the answer plus the number you took away should give the number you started with. For 52 − 27 = 25, check that 25 + 27 = 52.


Keep reading: our lesson Column subtraction and the opposite operation, Column addition.

Find out where your child stands in 20 minutes

The EasyMaths assessment is free: around thirty varied questions covering the whole year’s curriculum, with clear results skill by skill and the exercises to work on next.

Take the free assessment →

In the curriculum: Grade 2 (Year 2) · Grade 3 (Year 3) · Grade 4 (Year 4)